This article highlights appeals, penalties, and score adjustments logged during the 2023 NOBULL CrossFit Games season.
See below for more information on the appeals process in live and online competition:
- How Appeals Works During Live CrossFit Games Competition
- The Video Review Process and Best Practices
To view the appeals, penalties, and score adjustments from each stage of competition, see the reports below.
The Games
Day 1
Test 1
Name: Debbie Corwin (Women's 60-64)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the load is incorrect on the leaderboard.
Resolution: Appeal granted. The leaderboard will be changed to 130 lb.
Test 3
Miley Wade (Girls 14-15)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscommunicated no reps.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Cesar Tihista (Boys 14-15)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated another athlete took their lane.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon video review, the athlete was correct. Time will be adjusted to 8:05.
Shanna Bunce (Women's 55-59)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge had them do 2 additional repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Pauline Sciascia (Women's 65+)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated they weren't provided with the correct equipment (12-inch riser) in their lane.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Hailey Rolfe (Girls 16-17)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge made the wrong call on 11 no reps.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Stacie Tovar (Women's 35-39)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge held them to an unfair standard compared to other athletes.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands.
David Levey (Men's 45-49)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge held them to an unfair standard compared to other athletes.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands.
Jeremie Jourdan (Boys 14-15)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge held them to an unfair standard compared to other athletes.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands.
Antonio Silvestro (Multi-Extremity)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge had them do 5 additional repetitions of kettlebell swings during Round 1.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Score/time will be adjusted accordingly.
Mijail Pedrini (Multi-Extremity)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions of pull-ups in Round 3.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Score/time will be adjusted accordingly.
Day 2
Test 4
Tom Muhlbeier (65+)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the leaderboard is incorrect based on finish order.
Resolution: Appeal granted. The leaderboard will be changed to second place. Appeal retained.
Stuart Swanson (Men 60-64)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their Judge held them to the incorrect standard on the sled pull.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Athlete was held to an incorrect standard. Score/time will be adjusted accordingly.
Yvonne Howard (Women 60-64)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their Judge told them to advance the sled to the wrong position.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will retain appeal.
Tom Famaree (Men 60-64)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the leaderboard is incorrect based on finish order.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Day 3
Test 7
Andrea Di Salvatore (Men 45-49)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon video review, the athlete was correct. Time will be adjusted.
Deanna Posey (Women 40-44)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated that another athlete impeded their ability to progress through the test.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Reese Littlewood (Girls 16-17)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon video review, the athlete was correct. Time will be adjusted.
Jenna Michelotti (Girls 16-17)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the leaderboard is incorrect based on finish order.
Resolution: Appeal denied. The leaderboard is correct. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Jeremie Jourdan (Boys 14-15)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the time is incorrect on the leaderboard.
Resolution: Appeal denied. The leaderboard is correct. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Test 8
Jose Luna Alpizar (Boys 14-15)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge held them to an unfair standard compared to other athletes.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Andreia Pinheiro (Women 40-44)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge held them to an unfair standard compared to other athletes.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Ruling on the floor stands. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Day 4
Test 2
Amanda Barnhart (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Score will be adjusted accordingly.
Test 3
Katrin Davidsdottir (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Upon review, it was determined that the correct number of repetitions was performed. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Test 5
Cole Sager (Individual Men)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Upon review, it was determined that the correct number of repetitions was performed. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Test 6
Matilde Garnes (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Upon review, it was determined that the correct number of repetitions was performed. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Day 5
Test 8
Seher Kaya (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Time will be adjusted accordingly.
Elisa Fuliano (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal Granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Time will be adjusted accordingly.
Shelby Neal (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated the leaderboard is incorrect based on finish order.
Resolution: Appeal granted. The leaderboard will be changed to the corrected time/placement.
Sam Kwant (Individual Men)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal denied. Upon review, it was determined that the correct number of repetitions was performed. Athlete will lose one appeal.
Roman Khrennikov (Individual Men)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the athlete completed an extra box jump-over. Time will be adjusted accordingly.
Day 6
Test 11
Arielle Loewen (Individual Women)
Appeal Details: Athlete stated their judge miscounted the total number of completed repetitions.
Resolution: Appeal granted. Upon review, it was determined that the number of repetitions was incorrect. Time will be adjusted accordingly.
Semifinals
Individual and Team Semifinals
Quarterfinals